We tried an experiment tonight. Hallie, Hadley, and Natalie all saw their first movie, Charlotte’s Web, with their moms at a 5:30 showing. It was an interesting evening.
The theater was almost empty and the girls were really quite good. There was a bit of wiggling and seat shifting and chatting, but they also paid a lot of attention to the movie. Hallie watched most attentively and seemed a bit bothered when Natalie tried to talk to her.
I had given Hallie a story summary and we talked a bit about how the spider would die and why when we first made plans to see the movie. We ended going two days later than we’d planned, though, and I neglected to do a refresher. I think that was a mistake. I could see Hallie getting concerned at the end, and when the movie was over she was starting to talk to me about how she felt. Just then Hadley took a tumble and conked her teeth on the seat in front of her. In the rush that followed to make sure that Hadley was OK, Hallie’s emotions got pushed aside.
As we checked on Hadley, who wasn’t very upset but did have a cut in her gums, and talked about taking her to WakeMed to check things out, Hallie got nearly hysterical. I think it was a redirection of the emotion from the movie. She wailed when she didn’t get to see inside Hadley’s mouth. And after they left she was barely coherent when she told me she didn’t want Hadley to leave b/c she had wanted to tell her she’d been born at WakeMed. Explaining it was a different WakeMed didn’t help.
Hallie wailed most of the way home. We started trying to think of things that would help her feel better. Getting ready to go to Gum and Gup’s house helped some: “that makes me feel a little better but I’m still going to be crying all night.” The idea of more Christmas presents at their house helped some, too, “but only if we go there right now and we open the presents immediately, as soon as we get there.”
But the big quote of the night came when we were talking about Charlotte’s death. I had explained several different ways about how spiders don’t live very long, she’d been a good friend to Wilbur, she had done her work by laying her eggs, etc. etc. At one point I said, “She had her babies and they will have babies and those babies will have babies and on and on.” Hallie thought about this for a minute and then, through her wails, articulately phrased one of the biggest questions of all time. “How did the first baby on the earth ever get born if there wasn’t any one else around?”
As I stumbled around for a response, her wails continued as she choked out “If I could just figure out the answer to that one thing, I’d be a lot happier!” So would a lot of people! And I have to say I didn’t address her question very well because I spent the whole second half of the drive trying to remember it so I could write it down.
She had a weepy dinner but by the time we got snuggled in for stories she was pretty much settled down. I haven’t yet decided whether or not it was a mistake to take her tonight. Some of that will depend on how she is tomorrow. I’m definitely not going to bring things up, but I’ll follow her lead. She’s been very open and matter-of-fact talking about death in the past–she’ll often refer to Monty (my parents’ Berner) dying several months ago in a sad but straightforward way–which is why I thought this movie would be OK. I’ll be interested to hear what she says tomorrow, and I’m eager to know what Suzie and Stephanie hear from their girls. Hallie’s almost a year older than Natalie and a bit more than that over Hadley. It may be that she understood enough more to make it a bigger issue for her.